SleepGuy wrote:Exactly what do you mean by "inhalation therapy?" I'm confused. My son takes steriods through an inhaler to treat his asthma. He's also had steroids asministered at the hospital through "inhalation therapy." I don't know what that has to do with the PurSlee products (or Vicks, Glade, or any other aromatic product that imparts pleasant smells through natural or artificial aromatics). I suppose they are all "inhalation therapy"?
Inhalation therapy refers to the practice of administration of medications via directly to the lungs to achieve a desired effect. While generally used to achieve a local effect (in the case of MDIs and nebulizer treatment) certainly systemic effects may occur as well. This is relevant to the discussion and clearly shown in your citation from Goel showing improvement in sleep quality following short-term exposure to (8 minutes contact time) to the essential oil lavender. I have carefully reviewed that complete article and although the study sample is small, the data are there. And if people are claiming that essential oils and/or cosmetic oils help them to initiate sleep, maintain sleep, and/or accept CPAP (through CPAP desensitization) then fine, I will not argue the point. On the contrary I embrace it. As I have said repeatedly, complementary and alternative medicine including aromatherapy may have a very important role in a variety of situations. But to answer the question specifically, inhalation therapy (and we can use "aromatherapy" if you're more comfortable with that term) is about intent, using aromatherapy as a sleep aid or to help with CPAP desensitization, where "Glade" and "Downy" are inadvertent contacts (although I suppose it wouldn't appear that way looking at the commercials for those products).
Inhalation Therapy and Alternative Medicine
Inhalation therapy also has a role to play in folk remedies, which vary from effective to useless. For instance, inhalation therapy can be administered at home via a vaporizer or humidifier in your child’s room. Both devices are recognized as effective ways to ease many upper respiratory conditions. In addition, a treatment as basic as inhaling steam from a pot of hot water can provide some relief from congestion-related conditions. When warm moist air is applied to the nose and throat, it begins to thin the mucus and drain the sinuses. It is a fast-acting process, without the bothersome side effects of drowsiness or rebound congestion. (For optimum effects, the user should remain in a warm environment for at least one hour after the inhalation treatment.)
SleepGuy wrote:I don't see much practical different between spashing Aqua-Velva on my face in the morning (and smelling the artificial FOs in it--probably about 30% with 70% perfumers alcohol)
Hey, I've seen those numbers before...
The 30-70 Rule
Now I don't know who that babe is or what her qualifications are, but that seems like an interesting road to travel. If we're going to use cosmetic oils for inhalation therapy, why not use pharmaceutical grade? Doesn't it seem that would put the entire safety issue to bed (so to speak)?
SleepGuy wrote: Because the PurSleep fragrance oils do not contact the body
Don't be silly. Of course they do. You said they did with limbo or whatever system and all that. And you initially brought up Goel, not me.
SleepGuy wrote: it is not necessary to use "cosmetic grade" fragrance oil.
For inhalation therapy? You're saying you can use "industrial grade"? Industrial grade doesn't mean more durable, it means more contaminated.
SleepGuy wrote: Even fabric softeners (which are heavily scented) are not cosmetics even though they do come into contact with the body and lungs through extended dermal and inhalation exposure.
So they
do come into contact with the body. Now I'm getting confused (again).
SleepGuy wrote: While I have said that all questions are fair about PurSleep products, I am surprised that you don't seem to be applying the same level of scrutiny to other products (like Vics) that would seem to present much more real risk due to the widespread use by children, the petrolatum, and the use of camphor essential oil. The Vics products in particular have been on the market for over 100 years and are intended specifically for "inhalation therapy" all night. You have said nothing of fabric softener products, which are inhaled for many hours a day and absorbed through the skin. It would seem that risks posed by such aromatic produts should also be considered along with the PurSleep products.
Get serious. I saw you stomping around in the Vaseline thread, I must've put up half a hunnert posts about that. And brought attention to
LoQ's citation in re: Vicks VapoRub here.
SleepGuy wrote:you do not use these products
I never said that.
SleepGuy wrote:though you seem to have a great deal of personal interest in them for whatever reason....
Actually it's about a 50-50 personal/professional split. If aromatherapy can safely improve sleep quality and CPAP compliance I'd be crazy not to support it. And if employing synthetic cosmetic-grade fragrance oils is similarly effective as a sleep aid (and show me
any documentation that says synthetic cosmetic-grade fragrance oils qualify for aromatherapy), then I'll not only support it, I'll show where you can get
24 times as much high quality COs for the same price as PurSleep.
LorAnn Cosmetic Oils
However, my "short-list" of acceptable aromatherapy products remains pretty short right now.
SAG