rooster wrote:jnk phone wrote:........The bottom line is that there is now a consensus that there is some difference in modern scientific approach and modern religious approach to some questions. ...........jeff
Jeff,
You use the word "some". Would you please specify just one itty bitty question where the approaches are different by consensus?
If you are driving while typing on that phone please stop. I will mostly be away the next three days and we have plenty of time to discuss this if you keep yourself alive.
Do you want my scientific answer or my religious one?
Wait, I have to change lanes. There. OK. Where was I? (Please ignore that philosophical question.)
Actually, I think Songbird made the point best and most succinctly earlier in this thread: 'Holy books were not written to be science textbooks.' Or recipe books. Or diesel manuals. But they have their place. (OK, I embellished a little.)
Useful information about the way things work can be found through the scientific method. So the point I was making with the "some" statement was what followed in that paragraph: Don't bother your science teacher with questions of doctrine. And "that's the way God made it" isn't the answer anyone wants when they need an answer to a scientific question, although, personally, I like that answer for many things. That's why you don't go to a doc of divinity to help you with your biology homework, or to get your car worked on, or for a good recipe for lasagna. There's no chapter and verse for that. That's not his/her thing. And, similarly, I don't mind if my doctor is religious, I think it is kind of nice if he is. But I don't want him taking a religious
approach over a scientific one when he gives me my checkup and I need surgery or a pill.
Science addresses many questions well that aren't religious in nature, and religion (and photon-philosophers) address questions that the scientific method wasn't designed to address. Like questions of ultimate origin.
Why are those famous words of Steve Martin now ringing in my ear?:
"You just can't believe in anything anymore. I mean, religion is so arbitrary and mythological. And science is just pure empiricism and by virtue of its methods it excludes metaphysics. I guess I wouldn't believe in anything anymore if it weren't for my lucky-astrology-mood-watch!"--Steve Martin.
Man, my spelling and grammar have always been bad, but I can't believe how bad it is on that little keyboard on my phone. What a messy post that I can't even clean up now!