johnnygoodman wrote:
Why do some topics have the scrolling icon and some show the avatars?
Short Answer: If you post your avatar, that shows. If not, the default scrolling icons show.
Long Answer: All you VFW guys please bear with me - here goes some mushy reasoning. CPAPtalk is a warm place in a sea of cold websites. The secret sauce is all of you. People put themselves out there with threads like "2 Days Into CPAP and Struggling", which is hard to do in front of a bunch of strangers, and we come back with our stories, our advice, our support. A few years ago people started posting their real pictures (or real baby pictures) to CPAPtalk as their avatar. I thought this was an awesome development. I think it is critical that newbies see as many smiling faces of successful CPAP users as possible.
Cut to the redesign - we thought it was important that we have big bold titles right on the main page. However, all of those red and blue circles weren't getting it done. CPAPtalk was cold. We wanted to tell people about CPAPtalk very quickly, and we didn't have space for 1000 words, so we put your pictures up there.
The good with this approach is that everyone who comes to CPAPtalk can now "get it" quickly. The bad is that sometimes you get the standard icons and sometimes you get faces. Its not very consistent design.
I pushed for us to launch it this way and see how people reacted before making further mods. We are seriously considering printing blank when no avatar is listed, showing avatars when they are available and using the "take me to the newest post in a thread I haven't read" little box to the left of the title for people who want to see everything they've not read.
I like the idea of the poster's avatar being used here, but, to me, it doesn't look good mixed in with the "red circle thingies,"---as you said, not consistent. Since the avatars are square, maybe the other icons could be square, too, a little box like you suggest, that's either blank or has something in the box that would be the same for each one that doesn't have an avatar. Make sense?
Oh, and I never really understood why forums have some type of notation (bomb, scrolling thing) to indicate a "hot" topic. If it has a bunch of pages listed, or 1,000 posts it's obvious it's a hot topic! LOL
Pam