Update on my situation (to June 2008)
It's good to hear from you James.
Thanks for the update.
O.
Thanks for the update.
O.
_________________
Mask: AirFit™ P10 Nasal Pillow CPAP Mask with Headgear |
Additional Comments: Machine: Resmed AirSense10 for Her with Climateline heated hose ; alternating masks. |
And now here is my secret, a very simple secret; it is only with the heart that one can see rightly, what is essential is invisible to the eye.
Antoine de Saint-Exupery
Good advice is compromised by missing data
Forum member Dog Slobber Nov. 2023
Antoine de Saint-Exupery
Good advice is compromised by missing data
Forum member Dog Slobber Nov. 2023
I think:
1. you should have the nasal surgery but NOT have it done by the ENT that is reluctant to do it. You want a ENT surgeon with confidence that can help you, I would not use Ruddy that is for sure.
2. IF the MMA surgeon says he can only gain 5mm advancement and it doesn't sound like he is too confident he can obtain that. Seems like a lot of pain for not much expected gain. In the mean time, I would continue down the path using the dental device even working with Dentist to modify the MAD with a tube so you can breathe, it is my understanding that the Tap II device is capable of 4-5mm advancement. However, keep in mind that mouth breathing leads to a swollen tongue and that can make the situation even worse.
If nasal congestion is a contributing factor, I would have that taken care of FIRST, I would have it done before your health deteriorates any further or insurance runs out. Note: if your health continues to deteriorate no surgeon will want to proceed with any procedure.
I do not know what type of MAD dental device you are using, but positive things have been said about the SomnoMed MAS device:
http://www.somnomed.com.au/about-us.html
http://www.ihatecpap.com/oral_appliance.html
This site has about all of them listed, be careful in your selection you want a device that won't break and you want it easily adjustable. And I wouldn't rely so much on the Dentist experience with a particular device (unless you see them laying all over the place in their office) because the difficulty with the dental device is finding a qualified dentist with experience.
If it were me, I would seek out a Dentist specializing in Pros (Prosodontist). These Dentists specialize in making dental prosthesis and/or dentures, bridges and implants and the treatment of TMJ related disorders. They pay special attention the prosthesis doesn't cause alignment problems with the TMJ joint. In other words they would be the most qualified to advance your mandible without causing harm to the TMJ joint. As many Prosodontist are also trained in surgery for implantation of dental implants they would also have great contacts for MMA surgery and recommendations. Most do their own lab work so they could make any modifications to the MAD device without having to farm it out to some dental lab. You can have a great Dentist but if they use a lousy dental lab that can be a problem.
1. you should have the nasal surgery but NOT have it done by the ENT that is reluctant to do it. You want a ENT surgeon with confidence that can help you, I would not use Ruddy that is for sure.
2. IF the MMA surgeon says he can only gain 5mm advancement and it doesn't sound like he is too confident he can obtain that. Seems like a lot of pain for not much expected gain. In the mean time, I would continue down the path using the dental device even working with Dentist to modify the MAD with a tube so you can breathe, it is my understanding that the Tap II device is capable of 4-5mm advancement. However, keep in mind that mouth breathing leads to a swollen tongue and that can make the situation even worse.
If nasal congestion is a contributing factor, I would have that taken care of FIRST, I would have it done before your health deteriorates any further or insurance runs out. Note: if your health continues to deteriorate no surgeon will want to proceed with any procedure.
I do not know what type of MAD dental device you are using, but positive things have been said about the SomnoMed MAS device:
http://www.somnomed.com.au/about-us.html
http://www.ihatecpap.com/oral_appliance.html
This site has about all of them listed, be careful in your selection you want a device that won't break and you want it easily adjustable. And I wouldn't rely so much on the Dentist experience with a particular device (unless you see them laying all over the place in their office) because the difficulty with the dental device is finding a qualified dentist with experience.
If it were me, I would seek out a Dentist specializing in Pros (Prosodontist). These Dentists specialize in making dental prosthesis and/or dentures, bridges and implants and the treatment of TMJ related disorders. They pay special attention the prosthesis doesn't cause alignment problems with the TMJ joint. In other words they would be the most qualified to advance your mandible without causing harm to the TMJ joint. As many Prosodontist are also trained in surgery for implantation of dental implants they would also have great contacts for MMA surgery and recommendations. Most do their own lab work so they could make any modifications to the MAD device without having to farm it out to some dental lab. You can have a great Dentist but if they use a lousy dental lab that can be a problem.
someday science will catch up to what I'm saying...
Good to hear from you, James.
I hope they figure out what to do with you, pretty soon.
I also agree with Rooster about doctors only diagnosing what they know.
Hang in there, my friend.
Den
I hope they figure out what to do with you, pretty soon.
I also agree with Rooster about doctors only diagnosing what they know.
Hang in there, my friend.
Den
(5) REMstar Autos w/C-Flex & (6) REMstar Pro 2 CPAPs w/C-Flex - Pressure Setting = 14 cm.
"Passover" Humidification - ResMed Ultra Mirage FF - Encore Pro w/Card Reader & MyEncore software - Chiroflow pillow
User since 05/14/05
"Passover" Humidification - ResMed Ultra Mirage FF - Encore Pro w/Card Reader & MyEncore software - Chiroflow pillow
User since 05/14/05
- deerslayer
- Posts: 1195
- Joined: Tue Dec 11, 2007 10:46 am
- Location: Mid Tn
Good Idea ! ....i will make a deposit right now & thank you soo much James, you da man !Babette wrote:Good man, Jeff!!!JeffH wrote:For those using James's software, there is a Paypal button on his site. If you are using it and haven't made a contribution, he could probably use it about now.
http://james.istop.com/EncoreProAnalyzer/
Babs
RESMED AUTOSET 11/ P 10 NASAL PILLOWS /straight cpap 11.50/ AHI 1.0 per hr
Feeling Blessed & firmly believe in The Holy Trinity
Feeling Blessed & firmly believe in The Holy Trinity
- jskinner
- Posts: 1475
- Joined: Sat Aug 26, 2006 9:21 pm
- Location: Greenwich, Nova Scotia, Canada
- Contact:
I agree Snoredog. I am thankful for Ruddy since he hasn't given up on me (like some doctors) and keeps referring me to other specialists. I wish he had done more sooner but I am thankful for him keep trying. I've been referred to a 'more agressive' ENT in Dartmouth. The appointment is in Sept 2 so that's really what I am holding on to for some hope at this point.Snoredog wrote:1. you should have the nasal surgery but NOT have it done by the ENT that is reluctant to do it. You want a ENT surgeon with confidence that can help you, I would not use Ruddy that is for sure.
Yes its hard to know what to do. Because of that, I contacted Dr Kasey K. Li, one of the co-creators of the MMA procedure. He said about the same thing as my MMA surgon but also felt it was a worth while effort to try the procedure. He said the results might not be 100% in my case but there should be improvement.Snoredog wrote: 2. IF the MMA surgeon says he can only gain 5mm advancement and it doesn't sound like he is too confident he can obtain that. Seems like a lot of pain for not much expected gain.
Yes I took this approach for quite a few months. http://james.istop.com/apnea/reports/Device.jpg However not being able to swallow normally with the MAD in place and the CPAP air really did a number on my throat. (not to mention the dreweling you get) Also having that much contraption on made it hard to sleep. I still add the MAD now again to CPAP but can't use it for more than a couple of nights with my throat getting too irritated.Snoredog wrote: In the mean time, I would continue down the path using the dental device even working with Dentist to modify the MAD with a tube so you can breathe, it is my understanding that the Tap II device is capable of 4-5mm advancement.
Yep discovered that problem.Snoredog wrote:However, keep in mind that mouth breathing leads to a swollen tongue and that can make the situation even worse.
I completely agree, I plan to do that if I can get someone to do something to the nose. However if the MMA surgery date comes available I will likely proceed as I have been waiting since Nov 2007 for that so far. I looked into getting MMA done in the US and its $75,000.Snoredog wrote: If nasal congestion is a contributing factor, I would have that taken care of FIRST, I would have it done before your health deteriorates any further or insurance runs out.
I have no insurance so I'm lucky that health care if free (but slow) in Canada.
I use the Klearway. http://www.klearway.com/ I been pretty happy with it. It certainly helps but is not nearly as good as CPAP. I think dental devices should be tried more. They are very conformable compared to CPAP. For certain individuals they should work quite well.Snoredog wrote: I do not know what type of MAD dental device you are using, but positive things have been said about the SomnoMed MAS device:
Encore Pro Analyzer Author
Facebook Apnea Group
Facebook Apnea Group
- jskinner
- Posts: 1475
- Joined: Sat Aug 26, 2006 9:21 pm
- Location: Greenwich, Nova Scotia, Canada
- Contact:
If I was still in Ottawa I would check him out. I have lived in 4 different places since this problem started so I don't think it can be environmental. There certainly is an allergic factor since things get worse if I get my allergies acting up to but its never really seemed like an allergic reaction.Claire wrote:Question: Did you ever try an environmental doc? There's one in Ottawa called Mickelson
And what is that method?Claire wrote:He used an unorthodox (according to regular allergists) way of testing for food sensitivities and hit them all on the nose.
Encore Pro Analyzer Author
Facebook Apnea Group
Facebook Apnea Group
- jskinner
- Posts: 1475
- Joined: Sat Aug 26, 2006 9:21 pm
- Location: Greenwich, Nova Scotia, Canada
- Contact:
I'm pretty sure you would get tired of my complaining about the medial system and my grumpinessBabette wrote: Can't be any worse than me living alone and moping about. At least we could console each other.
Encore Pro Analyzer Author
Facebook Apnea Group
Facebook Apnea Group
- jskinner
- Posts: 1475
- Joined: Sat Aug 26, 2006 9:21 pm
- Location: Greenwich, Nova Scotia, Canada
- Contact:
Believe me I have tried. APAP used to work pretty good for me before the nasal issues. Trust me I have been trying to get to the bottom of it.xyz wrote:Personally, I would try really hard to get APAP to work as well as possible before trying surgery. And especially so with a prognosis like that.
Been tested for mold several times since this problems started. Also stoped using CPAP for 6 months so its not the tubing or anything that I am allergic to.xyz wrote: After too long I learned that I am sensitive to what I was cleaning mask/hose/humidifier with. In addition, I was found allergic to miildew and mold. I thought of this when reading your post.
Now I have a backup/spare for all items. I rinse them with vinegar to kill the germs. I wash them with Seventh Generation Free and Clear and then rinse really well. I rinse again with distilled water. And I let them set for a couple days before swapping back into the rotation.
I'm pretty happy with the Liberty (I use the Hybrid as a backup)xyz wrote: Try the Quattro full face mask. The F&Ps have kind of a peculiar fit. A FF mask that fits well gives you a better chance of getting some air in you.
I am defiantly better all around than I was 12 or even 6 months ago. There where times where I didn't think I was going to make it sine I couldn't breath. Apnea is pretty under control (AHI about 5-7) but my nose breathing is still not normal and CPAP use irritates it every night. By morning things are swollen up again in there. At least now things open up during the day so I can live a pretty normal life most days (with the help of sudafed twice a day)
Encore Pro Analyzer Author
Facebook Apnea Group
Facebook Apnea Group
- jskinner
- Posts: 1475
- Joined: Sat Aug 26, 2006 9:21 pm
- Location: Greenwich, Nova Scotia, Canada
- Contact:
My focus right now is to just get better... down the road its certainly something I am going to consider.DreamStalker wrote:Sounds like a multi-malpractice suite in the making
Encore Pro Analyzer Author
Facebook Apnea Group
Facebook Apnea Group
- jskinner
- Posts: 1475
- Joined: Sat Aug 26, 2006 9:21 pm
- Location: Greenwich, Nova Scotia, Canada
- Contact:
I remember when I first joined the board. I was so relieved to finally know what was wrong with me. I felt so much better after starting CPAP (although did struggle getting AHI down). Little did I know that the worst was yet to come. I had a great time writing that software. Really glad people find it useful. I had so much more that I was going to add, hopefully I can get back to it sometime.rested gal wrote:James, I've followed your posts ever since you came to the cpaptalk message board. I admire you for so many things, including the gift you gave so many here with your wonderful Encore Pro Analyzer.
Trust me at times I didn't have much determination left...rested gal wrote:But most of all I've admired your determination to keep going in the face of so many deadends in your search to get healthy again.
And thank you for all the things you do for this board! Your kindness to the group and personally has been much appreciated.rested gal wrote:Thank you so much for the update. You have many friends here -- and we're all pulling for you!!
-James
Last edited by jskinner on Thu Jul 24, 2008 11:06 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Encore Pro Analyzer Author
Facebook Apnea Group
Facebook Apnea Group
- jskinner
- Posts: 1475
- Joined: Sat Aug 26, 2006 9:21 pm
- Location: Greenwich, Nova Scotia, Canada
- Contact:
5mm.Anonymous wrote:Ask the doc what is the mm can be increased is the surgery is done. Then, check back to with me the mm figure.
Details are at http://james.istop.com/apnea/reports/GooddayReport.pdf
Encore Pro Analyzer Author
Facebook Apnea Group
Facebook Apnea Group
James: what about head and neck position to influence airflow dynamics?
What I mean by this is exploring ways to change the position of the head and neck while you sleep to open up the airway. This is similar to what is done to open the airway when performing CPR breathing.
In this case that position is "found" and then held in place with a special neck brace that is worn during sleep. Now I realize if you slept horizontal in a conventional bed this could be quite uncomfortable. But if the bed was elevated to compensate for the new position, it could be just enough to get you by until a surgery solution is obtainable.
I would touch base with a Chiropractor about it, take your MMA xray with you, they work with neck braces all the time, they may be able to offer you some relief. Too bad you were not close to the SF bay area, my chiropractor is semi-retired and only charges $35 a visit (probably $50 now).
If you want to do your own research, search for Oral airflow dynamics, maybe split-city has some additional info/links on it, but below is one and I'll add others. The ones citing UCLA School of Dentistry I may be able to get more info on, I sorta have a contact there.
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articl ... id=2269117
http://www.springerlink.com/content/t18pe116ygg7fvu7/
What I mean by this is exploring ways to change the position of the head and neck while you sleep to open up the airway. This is similar to what is done to open the airway when performing CPR breathing.
In this case that position is "found" and then held in place with a special neck brace that is worn during sleep. Now I realize if you slept horizontal in a conventional bed this could be quite uncomfortable. But if the bed was elevated to compensate for the new position, it could be just enough to get you by until a surgery solution is obtainable.
I would touch base with a Chiropractor about it, take your MMA xray with you, they work with neck braces all the time, they may be able to offer you some relief. Too bad you were not close to the SF bay area, my chiropractor is semi-retired and only charges $35 a visit (probably $50 now).
If you want to do your own research, search for Oral airflow dynamics, maybe split-city has some additional info/links on it, but below is one and I'll add others. The ones citing UCLA School of Dentistry I may be able to get more info on, I sorta have a contact there.
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articl ... id=2269117
http://www.springerlink.com/content/t18pe116ygg7fvu7/
someday science will catch up to what I'm saying...
Just show up pizza delivery!! LOLjskinner wrote:I'm pretty sure you would get tired of my complaining about the medial system and my grumpinessBabette wrote: Can't be any worse than me living alone and moping about. At least we could console each other.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jNW4Rnx0kxk
someday science will catch up to what I'm saying...