Scared after using smelly water

"When in doubt throw it out" it costs a couple of dollars to replace.
I think you did the right thing, maybe someone having a little fun with ya(?) and you still have your senses, your common sense.
My wife tells me that plastics will leach into contents under heat .

She might be right-ya ever smell burning plastic?
BPA was a huge cash cow for the container industry.
You can make a lot of money by scaring people.
Too bad they don't get scared by the TRUTH about tobacco!
Hold your breath when leaving and entering the building!

If you start growing an extra arm... let us know!

Sheriff

Teratogenesis, cool word--horrible condition!