Lucyhere,
I'm responding to your post by adding my remarks to Pugsy's post with some additions of my own.
Pugsy wrote:Lucyhere wrote:
Robysue and Pugsy...
Why is it that you protect him and have from the beginning of this thread?
Not RobySue but here's my thoughts.
PR has the exact same rights here and everyone else...now I know you don't like that fact but that's the fact despite your wanting to get people to feel your way is the "right" way. Remember...it's Johnny's sand box and not Lucy's sandbox.
Pugsy pretty much sums up my own thoughts in terms of PR.
Pugsy wrote:(addressing Lucyhere) I don't think I have "protected" him anyone more or less than anyone else who has been ugly here. I have publicly said that I cringe when I read what he sometimes writes. What more do you want me to say? You want me to spew the same level of vitriol that you spew...it ain't gonna happen....I won't do that to anyone.
I also do not think I have
protected PR any more or less than anybody else who I've seen being ugly.
Pugsy wrote:(addressing Lucyhere) You think because I didn't join your posse that I am protecting him??
I also can't help but wonder: Is this the reason you think that I and Pugsy are somehow protecting him?
Pugsy wrote:(addressing Lucyhere)
Remember...it's Johnny's sandbox...not yours...not mine...not anyone's but Johnny. We abide by Johnny's rules or decision to not make many rules if we want to play here. I will defend Johnny's rules though...and if Johnny has seen fit to not ban someone for ugly behavior...it's not my place to go up on the roof top and shout how ugly anyone is.
I agree with Pugsy here.
I'll also add that in my humble opinion it is not reasonable to lobby
forum members about how Johnny's rules should be changed.
If you think the rules should be changed, you can PM Johnny and Carolyn with your complaints about the current official rules and suggestions you have for changing those rules. But Johnny and Carolyn have the right
as the owners and administrators to ignore your suggestions if they want to.
Pugsy wrote:(addressing Lucyhere)I have the right to look for good in people...you have the right to look for bad in people...which IMHO is all you want to do.
I agree with Pugsy.
Pugsy wrote:(addressing Lucyhere) In this thread PR...and anyone else... which includes you...has the right to say anything they want.... ugly, right, wrong, indifferent...this isn't a helping thread. This is a duke it out thread and lord knows there's been a lot of duking here but I don't care.
Again, I agree with Pugsy. Heck I'll gladly defend anybody's right to duke it out here or on any other OT thread.
I'll also add: Pugsy and I don't make the forum rules and
we do NOT want to make the forum rules, but we do have the right to
request that others try to restrain themselves from duking it out in the middle of helping threads. And under Johnny's rules, other forum members have the right to ignore our request, but if you choose to ignore our request and decide to duke it out on the helping thread, I may ask you (politely) to take it elsewhere. I'll only ask once, and if you continue to ignore my request, I'll likely just start ignoring a lot of your posts in the helping threads, but I am likely to respond to your posts on the duke-it-out threads with language that makes it clear I think that I don't approve of duking it out on helping threads.
Pugsy wrote:(addressing Lucyhere) I am not forming...nor will I join...any lynch posse out to get anyone no matter how ugly they have been in the past or even how ugly they might be in the future. If you think that is "protecting" PR (or the numerous others who also have been ugly in the past..and that includes you) then I suppose that might be "protecting" but it's protecting everyone who has been guilty of derailing a helping thread and PR wasn't alone in saying hateful ugly things. You are getting the same "protection" if you think my not attacking someone means I am "protecting" them.
Like Pugsy, I am loathe to join posses and lynch mobs.
Pugsy wrote:(addressing the whole forum) It's simply a realization that there will always be heated, ugly, stupid fighting here...and if we are going to do it....TAKE IT OUT OF THE HELPING THREAD. How you all take it out of a helping thread...I really don't care...you all are supposed to be grown up adults and you all have to figure out on your own how you deal with ugliness...do you want to be part of the solution or continue to be part of the problem.
It doesn't mean that people can't disagree in a helping thread...all it means is please use a little common sense AND common courtesy when you are disagreeing so the focus doesn't change to so much ugly that the original intent of actually helping someone gets tossed right out the window.
When someone chimes in (in a helping thread) with nothing but "so and so is a jerk/whatever" and that's already either been pointed out or obvious...that's being part of the problem and not part of the solution...IMHO.
Two things are worth paraphrasing:
1) People can and
should feel free to disagree in a helping thread, but when you disagree with a poster in a helping thread, try to disagree using some common sense and
common courtesy.
2) When any one of you forum members posts
nothing but "so and so is a jerk (or more colorful language of your choice)" in a
helping thread when it's obvious that "so and so" is indeed a jerk and/or when others have already pointed it out in the helping thread, your post part of the problem and not part of the solution.