Re: Choosing a Battery
Posted: Wed Jun 19, 2019 3:16 pm
A lot of questions ... I'll try to get to them
Each battery should have a "ring to quick connector" tail bolted on (and taped) so it can be swapped in quickly. I use a simple box to make carrying easy, and a splitter to have multiple items connected.
However, there is nothing wrong with having it the tent. These are the same batteries thousands of seniors have in their mobility scooters.
For longest lifetime, we try to stay above 50% State Of Charge. Taking it down to 20% is still reasonable with the understanding that the number of cycles will be limited. Beyond that the battery will be damaged.
The AGM style battery fits the bill, with the understanding that they are made of lead, and weight = power.campervan wrote: ↑Wed Jun 19, 2019 11:13 am- can be set up and use safely, preferably inside a tent, around children and pets and uncoordinated adults
- can be stuck in the trunk of a small car with lots of other stuff, and possibly running a weatherproof DC extension cord from there, if they exist
- a relatively simple project for someone with no experience with batteries or wiring who does not want exposed wires hanging around
- cheap is best - $325 is my absolute max, $250 is a lot better, and $200 or less would be fantastic (but seems unlikely)
- would be great if it wasn't so heavy that it'd be terrible to lug from a car to a tent, or better, to carry maybe max 500 yards
- a DC port or two built in or easily/permanently installed would be fabulous
I like the Universal brand because I thought they had better reviews, but its a tossup ...campervan wrote: ↑Wed Jun 19, 2019 11:13 am
I think that this setup qualifies? But I'd like your opinions! So here's my plan:
1. Deep cycle AGM lead acid battery, 100 ah ($170):
https://www.amazon.com/Universal-UB1210 ... 00S1RT58C/
alternate #1: two 35 AH batteries ($135):
https://www.amazon.com/12VOLT-DEEP-CYCL ... 0BUH0TAS/
alternate #2: one 55 AH battery ($120):
https://www.amazon.com/Mighty-Max-Batte ... 0K898AT6/
alternate #3: one 35 AH battery ($65):
https://www.amazon.com/Mighty-Max-Batte ... 0K8E0WAG/
very spiffy, but possibly overkill. Its sized for a larger battery than the U1. Its easy to built the functionality with a 1 to 5 splitter and a few extra DC socket.campervan wrote: ↑Wed Jun 19, 2019 11:13 am
2. Battery box with built-in DC ports ($50):
https://www.amazon.com/MinnKota-Trollin ... 01PTHKMG/
I would go with a larger model if possibly. I use the 1.25 amp "Plus" version; I notice the 3amp version is $40 at Costco.campervan wrote: ↑Wed Jun 19, 2019 11:13 am
3. BatteryTender charger ($25):
https://www.amazon.com/Battery-Tender-0 ... 00CITK8S/
Normally the best advice is to join batteries together into the largest bank possible. However, since you're "carrying in" a ways, you're probably better served by two 35 AH batteries that are used separately. Batteries can be joined, but best practice is to only join similar sizes bought at the same time - my boat's house bank is four large batteries permanently joined. Otherwise, use them one at a time, - lug the depleted battery back to the car and get a fresh one.campervan wrote: ↑Wed Jun 19, 2019 11:13 am
4. ResMed DC to DC converter, product # 37297 ($65 - I got it cheap):
https://www.amazon.com/Resmed-37297-Air ... 721T72ML/
Total cost: 100/70/55/35 ah setup = $310/275/260/240
I have a bunch of questions if that's okay -
- What's my best bet in terms of size? I want to balance as many amp hours as possible with having something that is light enough that it won't kill an average person to carry it a couple hundred yards. If I can get a longer camping trip that's great, but I'm torn as I'd really love to keep costs down.
- If I wanted to buy one 35 AH battery for this trip, and pick up another when we'd be camping for longer next year, would that work without having to buy a different battery box? Would the box fit three if I added two later? Could I put a 35 AH battery in the same box with a 55 AH battery? Is the two-battery setup in any way less efficient than having only one? What happens if you have only half a night's charge on one of the batteries - can you set them up to run one after the other? This is where my electrical wiring ignorance comes through, sorry.
Each battery should have a "ring to quick connector" tail bolted on (and taped) so it can be swapped in quickly. I use a simple box to make carrying easy, and a splitter to have multiple items connected.
Using the splitter keeps mostly controlled. If you don't have something to fiddle with, where's the fun? With the quick connectors its easy to swap batteries - to my mind the box adds work if you have more than one battery.
AGM batteries were designed to be stuffed into fighter jets; they can handled harsh environments, including upside down.campervan wrote: ↑Wed Jun 19, 2019 11:13 am
- The battery would travel in the small crowded trunk of our car, where it would be unsecured by anything except its own weight (I'm not sure there would be anywhere to tie it down to in the trunk of a sedan.) Is that safe? Will the vibration of the car mess it up? What if it gets tipped over? Bumped? Dropped?
If the terminals are protected its totally safe. If it heats up, something is very, very wrong. You want to make absolutely sure nothing can short out the two terminals - the wires are protected by fuses, but if you were to lay a screwdriver across the terminals you would have a melted screwdriver!! This is why the box is recommended - you can get away with tape, but the box is better. If you're swapping batteries, tape up the lug and ring connector - the lugs should never be exposed.campervan wrote: ↑Wed Jun 19, 2019 11:13 am
- Can a battery setup like this be kept inside a tent, especially a crowded one with a kid? Does it become hot? Is it dangerous to have unvented? I'm assuming it's okay to run in a trunk, but is it okay for anything else to be in the trunk with it/crowding it/touching it?
However, there is nothing wrong with having it the tent. These are the same batteries thousands of seniors have in their mobility scooters.
You can certainly run an cord any reasonable distance, but the problem is that most such cords with SAE quick connectors are thin so once you go over 12 to 25 feet the voltage drop might hurt. If its only 50 feet then lug it into the tent - that way you can charge the phones overnight.campervan wrote: ↑Wed Jun 19, 2019 11:13 am
- The CPAP needs a DC converter, but I can't find any long waterproof DC extension cords that I could run from the CPAP in our tent to the battery box in the trunk of our car (50 feet would be ideal but this seems impossible.) Is thIs there a way I can have that DC port in use and protected from the elements, so that the converter could plug into the CPAP at one end, inside the tent, and then go through the tent door to plug into the battery box outside the tent at the other end? Or do I need to plan on using the battery in the tent?
Maybe in a few years - $600 might get you 45 amp-hours today. But Lithium is still evolving; lead/acid has been developed for 150 years. And its cheap to add another battery when your needs change.campervan wrote: ↑Wed Jun 19, 2019 11:13 am
- Lastly, is there a way I can get a minimum of 40-50 amp hours with a lightweight lithium ion setup for under $300? I am assuming no. The closer I can get this to $200, the better, but if the difference between $200 and $300 was 70 pounds and a bunch of work, the more expensive option sounds pretty good. I can't go over $325 max (and I will have a lot more money for vacation if I can do this cheaper) so I'd love some advice on what the real options are in my situation.
campervan wrote: ↑Wed Jun 19, 2019 11:13 am
Thanks! I really appreciate the help! I have read all the posts and just haven't quite wrapped my head around it all yet - I apologize for any questions whose answers I missed in what has already been written. I'll look forward to hearing what you have to say!