Months on CPAP and still struggling with aerophagia issues

General Discussion on any topic relating to CPAP and/or Sleep Apnea.
Spadin
Posts: 7
Joined: Sun Oct 27, 2024 4:21 pm

Months on CPAP and still struggling with aerophagia issues

Post by Spadin » Mon Oct 28, 2024 5:49 pm

Hello everyone, i'm new to cpaptalk I will try my best to explain my situation

I'm from france, so a lot of my equipment is not listed on the profile

APAP machine : Prisma Smart Max (Lowenstein, German provider)
Humidifier: Prisma Aqua
Mask : FFM BMC F5AS / N30i Resmed

Pressure : 7-9 APAP dynamic (Lowenstein has a "standard" and a dynamic algorythm)
Humidifier: It depends, but 3-5 usually
EPR : No*

** As a side note, we tried EPR before and it was making me feeling worse

My PSG without APAP was : 13,9 AHI (mainly hypopneas) / 17,4 RERA / Sleep architecture was awful with only 32 minutes REM sleep (with 6h30 total duration)

I struggled a lot at the begining because I had awful aerophagia, so we put on a 7 fixed pressure and EPR 2 for examples :

(Ignore "flow limitation" on oscar, lowenstein and oscar are struggling to display Flow limitation, UF1 UF2 are the true flow limitation, EG : https://www.apneaboard.com/wiki/index.p ... timization
screenshot-20241029-002545.png
screenshot-20241029-002545.png (97.12 KiB) Viewed 7055 times

After a bit of tweaking here and there (humidifier/ change EPR)

We tried a nasal cushions masks namely the N30i resmed (I still have it), and me and my wife discovered I had massive mouth leaks and I open my mouth to exhale, after that my mouth is just pumping out air non stop for a time and then stopping with an arousal and repeat the whole night

Exemple :
screenshot-20241029-003527.png
screenshot-20241029-003527.png (95.84 KiB) Viewed 7055 times
Then we understood that the aerophagia with the FFM was coming from opening my mouth to exhale, and then the air entered the stomach this way
I saw a tongue specialist that made me place my tongue correctly on the roof of the palate, did a lot of throat exercice

After the specialist visit we switch from Fixed pressure 7 and EPR 2 to APAP dynamic 7-9 and no EPR
screenshot-20241029-003946.png
screenshot-20241029-003946.png (93.72 KiB) Viewed 7055 times
Still not feeling that much better, Many of my symptoms have gone away (like sexsomnia, memory trouble, extreme tiredness)
but i still feel horrible waking up, still feeling tired (but way better than before cpap), and mood swing (same, better than before)

I saw that i have a lot of leak "Spikes" , and everytime i'm not doing a full cpap night, there's a leak spike right before my arousal ( in the two previous screenshot with FFM there's a leak spike right before my awakening and removing the mask unconsciously for example), anyway a lot of my night have these leak spikes, and the famous leak spike before arousal and removing the mask


Maybe that's the best clue I have for now ?

I tried mouth taping, 3m micropore, still leak spike
Soft cervical collar, same leak spike

Can someone help me with my situation ?
It would be a pleasure to answer any questions about my situation or clarification, sorry if something was not clear !

Thanks a lot for reading this block
Killian

User avatar
ozij
Posts: 10370
Joined: Fri Mar 18, 2005 11:52 pm

Re: Months on CPAP and still struggling

Post by ozij » Mon Oct 28, 2024 8:56 pm

Spadin wrote:
Mon Oct 28, 2024 5:49 pm
I saw that i have a lot of leak "Spikes" , and everytime i'm not doing a full cpap night, there's a leak spike right before my arousal ( in the two previous screenshot with FFM there's a leak spike right before my awakening and removing the mask unconsciously for example), anyway a lot of my night have these leak spikes, and the famous leak spike before arousal and removing the mask
Welcome to the forum, Kilian.
Looks like you've done a great job at getting a handle on the therapy the machine gives.
However, you're not sleeping enough hours with those therapy settings.
I understand how leak spikes can cause arousals, but I think the main problem is your response to them: removing your mask and continuing sleep without them, despite the arousals.

Which means you have to find ways of keeping yourself from removing the mask.
Do you have mittens or gloves you can sleep with?
Use the 3M Micropore tape to tape the straps to your face.
Does your machine have an "Auto off" option? If it does disable it - so that the machine will keep blowing and making noise when you've taken the mask off.

Last but not least, before you go to sleep tell yourself: "even if I wake up, even if there is a leak spike, I will not take off the mask, I will turn over and continue sleeping". You have to convince your unconscious that "taking off the mask is not an option."
You also have to be very clear about the fact that sleeping without the mask is not an option. In other words: if you've attempted to remove the mask and now you're unable to resume sleep then get out of bed, do something pleasant and relaxing (and or very boring) in another room, until you feel ready to sleep again - with the mask on. You have to be very firm (in a kind, not scolding way) that sleep time is mask time.

It's a learning process. Sleeping with a mask and pressurized air blowing in is not natural to us, and your unconscious has learned to avoid it, at least temporarily, by making you take the mask off and continuing to sleep without it. It may have learned it when the aerophagia was at its worst and sleep without the mask was such a relief. Not matter what the reason for this habit, It's a habit you now have to unlearn.

_________________
Mask: AirFit™ P10 Nasal Pillow CPAP Mask with Headgear
Additional Comments: Machine: Resmed AirSense10 for Her with Climateline heated hose ; alternating masks.
And now here is my secret, a very simple secret; it is only with the heart that one can see rightly, what is essential is invisible to the eye.
Antoine de Saint-Exupery

Good advice is compromised by missing data
Forum member Dog Slobber Nov. 2023

Spadin
Posts: 7
Joined: Sun Oct 27, 2024 4:21 pm

Re: Months on CPAP and still struggling

Post by Spadin » Tue Oct 29, 2024 9:35 am

ozij wrote:
Mon Oct 28, 2024 8:56 pm

Last but not least, before you go to sleep tell yourself: "even if I wake up, even if there is a leak spike, I will not take off the mask, I will turn over and continue sleeping". You have to convince your unconscious that "taking off the mask is not an option."
You also have to be very clear about the fact that sleeping without the mask is not an option. In other words: if you've attempted to remove the mask and now you're unable to resume sleep then get out of bed, do something pleasant and relaxing (and or very boring) in another room, until you feel ready to sleep again - with the mask on. You have to be very firm (in a kind, not scolding way) that sleep time is mask time.
Hello Ozij ! Thanks for your reply, Previous night I tried to understand what was going on, I awakenend very sleepy, Removed the mask, And there terrible stomach pains and burping

Seems like I have the same root problem with FFM or Nasal cushions, my mouth somehow open, and with FFM air goes to the stomach, and with nasal cushion air leak through mouth

Maybe I can give the soft collar or the tapping another go ? Or maybe another solution like inclined pillow or bed ? What do you think ?

I was too focused on the leaks and not on the feeling when I awaken last time

User avatar
ozij
Posts: 10370
Joined: Fri Mar 18, 2005 11:52 pm

Re: Months on CPAP and still struggling

Post by ozij » Sat Nov 02, 2024 10:47 pm

I was hoping someone who had more experience with aerophagia (air filled stomach and burping) would respond.
So I'm bumping this up.

_________________
Mask: AirFit™ P10 Nasal Pillow CPAP Mask with Headgear
Additional Comments: Machine: Resmed AirSense10 for Her with Climateline heated hose ; alternating masks.
And now here is my secret, a very simple secret; it is only with the heart that one can see rightly, what is essential is invisible to the eye.
Antoine de Saint-Exupery

Good advice is compromised by missing data
Forum member Dog Slobber Nov. 2023

Spadin
Posts: 7
Joined: Sun Oct 27, 2024 4:21 pm

Re: Months on CPAP and still struggling

Post by Spadin » Wed Nov 06, 2024 8:54 am

Hello again !

Thanks ozij for the bumping,

We switched to a fixed 7, but I kept getting awokenend by massive aerophagia,

I lost a lot of weight since 5-6 month (93 kg -> 81 kg), maybe that's what provoking the aerophagia ?

I slept without mask and the day after I felt horrible so I don't think my sleep apnea is cured, but maybe I just need a small pressure with humidity ?

With my lowenstein machine im already at max humidity (5) should I try to lower it ? Will it help with aerophagia ?

What cpaptalk think ?
I can provide oscar if you want

Killian

User avatar
robysue1
Posts: 1207
Joined: Sun Sep 18, 2022 3:39 pm
Location: Buffalo, NY

Re: Months on CPAP and still struggling

Post by robysue1 » Thu Nov 07, 2024 11:14 am

Spadin,

Ozij pm'd me asking me to look at your thread since I'm one of the long time posters who had had some pretty severe problems with aerophagia in the past.

You've written the following things:
Spadin wrote:
Mon Oct 28, 2024 5:49 pm
I struggled a lot at the begining because I had awful aerophagia, so we put on a 7 fixed pressure and EPR 2 for examples :
Spadin wrote:
Mon Oct 28, 2024 5:49 pm
We tried a nasal cushions masks namely the N30i resmed (I still have it), and me and my wife discovered I had massive mouth leaks and I open my mouth to exhale, after that my mouth is just pumping out air non stop for a time and then stopping with an arousal and repeat the whole night
Spadin wrote:
Mon Oct 28, 2024 5:49 pm
Then we understood that the aerophagia with the FFM was coming from opening my mouth to exhale, and then the air entered the stomach this way
I saw a tongue specialist that made me place my tongue correctly on the roof of the palate, did a lot of throat exercice
Spadin wrote:
Tue Oct 29, 2024 9:35 am
Hello Ozij ! Thanks for your reply, Previous night I tried to understand what was going on, I awakenend very sleepy, Removed the mask, And there terrible stomach pains and burping

Seems like I have the same root problem with FFM or Nasal cushions, my mouth somehow open, and with FFM air goes to the stomach, and with nasal cushion air leak through mouth
Spadin wrote:
Wed Nov 06, 2024 8:54 am
We switched to a fixed 7, but I kept getting awokenend by massive aerophagia,

I lost a lot of weight since 5-6 month (93 kg -> 81 kg), maybe that's what provoking the aerophagia ?
Aerophagia is caused by air getting into the oral cavity and then you swallow the air so it gets into your stomach. The tongue and throat exercises you were given by the tongue specialist are designed to train your body to keep your tongue in the correct place all night long when you're asleep. When the tongue is in the correct position, the nasal cavity is sealed off from the oral cavity and it is (essentially) impossible to swallow the "extra air" in the nasal cavity. At least that's the theory, but not everybody's upper airway has read the textbook.

My first question is: Are you still doing the tongue exercises? If not, start doing them again. My guess is those exercises will eventually "fix" the aerophagia problem in that if you keep doing them, the amount of time during the night when the tongue slips off the palate and allows air into the oral cavity will decrease. But when your stomach hurts really bad, the last thing you want to be told is that eventually the problem will start to go away. After all, the big question is, "How do I get some rest in the meantime without waking up in pain so often?"

So let's try to do some troubleshooting for what you can do to minimize the pain while your tongue is learning to stay in the right place to keep the air out of the oral cavity.

1) You might want to reconsider using the nasal mask again. Yes, you had some "massive" leaks from when you had your mouth open. But when the air was leaking directly out of your mouth, it was not going down into your stomach. With the full face mask, the air that has gotten into your oral cavity doesn't "escape" when you open your mouth since the mouth is under the mask and the oral cavity is also pressurized. So you may be unconsciously swallowing some excess air in a (futile) attempt to get rid of it. In other words, if you had less aerophagia when using the nasal mask, then you might be better off using the nasal mask (leaks and all) for a while and seeing if the tongue exercises (eventually) lead to fewer and shorter periods of leaking.

For what it's worth, the mouth leaks on the night of 8/8 that you posted are not the worst examples of mouth leaks that I've seen. Even at their worst, they're still small enough for your machine to not be calling them "official large leaks". So they're most likely not yet large enough to adversely affect the efficacy of your CPAP therapy. However, those leaks went on long enough to affect the quality of both your sleep and your wife's sleep since those leaks eventually woke you both up. Still, if you had less aerophagia with the nasal mask, the switching back to it may be a good idea. Keep doing the tongue exercises and give yourself the luxury of just not worrying about the leaks for a week or so. Focus on whether there's less aerophagia when using a nasal mask versus using the full face mask. If switching to the nasal mask brings the aerophagia under control, you can deal with "fixing" the leaks later.


2) Aerophagia is aggravated by many of the same things that aggravate night time acid reflux. So it's worth doing things like making sure you don't eat too close to bedtime. Sleep position is something to consider: If you're a side sleeper, sleeping on the left side is usually more comfortable for both aerophagia problems and acid reflux problems. Stomach sleeping can make both aerophagia and acid reflux worse, but back sleeping can help minimize them. Elevating the head of the bed might help or sleeping on a firm wedge. But just propping yourself up on a bunch of normal pillows might not do much to ease the problem. Some people will claim sleeping with your neck extended (as opposed to having your head curled toward your chest) will help, but that raises the question of whether sleeping in that position is so uncomfortable for you that you can't really sleep or not. I am someone who wants to sleep curled tightly into a little ball (i.e. fetal position), and so I never was willing to try using something like a soft cervical collar to force myself to keep my neck extended.


3) Aerophagia can be worse at higher pressures. Now the pressure you are using, 7cm, is not particularly high. But again, your mouth and stomach haven't read the textbook, and you are having problems with aerophagia at 7cm. You might want to try reducing the pressure just a bit, but that does risk increasing the AHI, potentially significantly. Or you might want to give dynamic mode another try. But if you try dynamic mode, I'd suggest a pressure range of 4-7cm rather than the 7-9cm that you tried before. (If breathing at 4cm makes you feel air starved, then bump that minimum pressure up to 5 or 6, but leave the max pressure at 7.)


4) When you wake up in the middle of the night wanting to take the mask off, ask yourself "What am I feeling? Why do I want to take the mask off?". Ozij has already given you some good advice on how to fight the tendency to just take the mask off and go back to sleep. I will add this, however: Sometimes that feeling of just wanting to take the mask off is triggered by the fear of aerophagia. Even now, I will sometimes wake up in the middle of the night with a stomach sending signals that it feels like it's on the verge of getting aerophagia. What I do when this happen is this: I turn the machine off, sit up in bed, and pull the mask away from my nose and simply relax sitting in bed for a few minutes while breathing through my nose. When I am ready to go back to sleep, it's easy to just let go of the mask and let it settle back on my nose and the turn the machine back on and lie back down to go to sleep. Note: I don't take the mask all the way off my head when I do this. Rather, I just gently pull the cushion far enough away from my face and nose that I can breathe "normally" for the few minutes that it takes my stomach and brain to settle down and decide they both want to go back to sleep.

If you wake up in the middle of the night with real aerophagia---as in your stomach is already feeling swollen and hurting, the best thing to do sometimes is to just get out of bed. Walk around for a few minutes and go to the bathroom. See if you can force yourself to get some of that excess air out through burping or farting. And go back to bed only after the stomach is feeling a bit better and you feel strong enough to face putting the mask on again. NOTE: This can be very difficult to do, but it's the only thing that I've found that works when I wake up with really bad aerophagia.


5) In general it's important that you are as comfortable as you can be when you are in bed trying to sleep. For some people, adding things like mouth tape, chin straps, soft cervical collars doesn't add any additional "comfort" issues. But for many of us, adding any of these things can make what seems like a difficult bedtime routine even more difficult. Sometimes, it's better to put comfort above the effort needed to reduce leaks to close to 0 or to reduce an already acceptable AHI close to 0. So for each of the things that you are doing or have tried, do an assessment: Does mouth taping add to my anxiety and discomfort? If so, ditch the mouth taping. (Taping the frame to your face to discourage taking the mask off in your sleep is separate from mouth taping.). Does putting on the chinstrap make me more uncomfortable? Is trying to sleep with a soft cervical collar making it more difficult to get to sleep? Only do the things that don't add any discomfort or anxiety at the beginning of your night.


6) You've asked whether turning your humidifier down might help the aerophagia. That's really a personal preference. My nose wants maximum humidification---if I turn my humidifier down, I'm more or less guaranteed to have a badly dried out nose in the morning. But other people find that their noses like a lot less humidification. Some people's noses don't want any additional humidity at all. In general when the humidity is too high, your nose will feel (or become) more congested using the CPAP than without it. And I suppose that if humidifier-induced congestion grows during the night, that might cause some mouth breathing, which requires the tongue to drop down off its proper location on the upper palate, which in turn could aggravate aerophagia. Turning down the humidifier is an easy experiment to try, and your nose will let you know (within a day or two) whether the new humidifier setting is too low for its comfort.


Finally, I want to address two other things you've said:
Spadin wrote:
Mon Oct 28, 2024 5:49 pm
Still not feeling that much better, Many of my symptoms have gone away (like sexsomnia, memory trouble, extreme tiredness)
but i still feel horrible waking up, still feeling tired (but way better than before cpap), and mood swing (same, better than before)
CPAP is a process. It sounds like your body is beginning to detect the benefits of having sleep apnea-free sleep: No sexsomnia, no memory problems, less extreme tiredness. But it's still working on figuring out this new way of sleeping, and because you're not yet sleeping well with the machine all night long, every single night, you're still feeling horrible when waking up and you still have more fatigue than you'd like. And you still have mood swings, but they're not as bad as before CPAP.

My guess is that you may never be a morning person who wakes up feeling great and ready to go every morning. As pugsy's signature puts it: I may have to rise, but I don't have to shine. Some of us are just not cut out to be morning people. But at the same time I think as you learn to sleep well with the machine and as you find a way to manage the aerophagia and keep it under tight control, your remaining symptoms will (slowly) start to get better.


You end your last post with this:
Spadin wrote:
Wed Nov 06, 2024 8:54 am
I slept without mask and the day after I felt horrible so I don't think my sleep apnea is cured, but maybe I just need a small pressure with humidity ?
Use this experience to keep yourself motivated: You know that when you sleep without the mask, you feel horrible because the untreated sleep apnea comes roaring back.

Sleeping with the mask is not easy at the beginning for a lot of people. But that single night without the CPAP has demonstrated to you that regardless of how tired or sleepy you still feel, sleeping with the mask makes you feel (at best) better than sleeping without it. When you're tempted to just take the mask off in the middle of the night and go back to sleep, remind yourself that putting the mask back on will make you less likely to feel as miserable as you felt the day after you slept without the mask.

Because the real secret to CPAPing is this simple: Once you start sleeping with the machine every night, all night long, that's when your body can really start to heal from all the damage the untreated sleep apnea caused.

Sometimes once the body starts to heal, it starts craving sleep and the so the excess sleepiness may stick around for a while. But eventually if a person doesn't give up on CPAPing, the body does start to heal and sleeping with the machine finally becomes second nature. And then you find yourself looking back at the early days of CPAPing wondering just why it took so long for your body and brain to settle down and accept this therapy so that you could get a really decent night's sleep every night.
Joined as robysue on 9/18/10. Forgot my password & the email I used was on a machine that has long since died & gone to computer heaven.

Correct number of posts is 7250 as robysue + what I have as robysue1

Profile pic: Frozen Niagara Falls

Spadin
Posts: 7
Joined: Sun Oct 27, 2024 4:21 pm

Re: Months on CPAP and still struggling

Post by Spadin » Sat Nov 09, 2024 7:26 am

Hello robysue !
robysue1 wrote:
Thu Nov 07, 2024 11:14 am

My first question is: Are you still doing the tongue exercises? If not, start doing them again. My guess is those exercises will eventually "fix" the aerophagia problem in that if you keep doing them, the amount of time during the night when the tongue slips off the palate and allows air into the oral cavity will decrease. But when your stomach hurts really bad, the last thing you want to be told is that eventually the problem will start to go away. After all, the big question is, "How do I get some rest in the meantime without waking up in pain so often?"
Yeah, I'm still doing tongue exercises time to time (like 3 times a week) , I will do them again everyday ! I do these exercises https://www.orofacial-myology.com/blog/ ... al%20times.
robysue1 wrote:
Thu Nov 07, 2024 11:14 am

1) You might want to reconsider using the nasal mask again.

For what it's worth, the mouth leaks on the night of 8/8 that you posted are not the worst examples of mouth leaks that I've seen. Even at their worst, they're still small enough for your machine to not be calling them "official large leaks". So
I will try again the nasal masaks ! It depends on the night, the leak can be really "massive"
for example
screenshot-20241109-140751.png
screenshot-20241109-140751.png (99.14 KiB) Viewed 5318 times
robysue1 wrote:
Thu Nov 07, 2024 11:14 am

2) Aerophagia is aggravated by many of the same things that aggravate night time acid reflux. So it's worth doing things like making sure you don't eat too close to bedtime. Sleep position is something to consider: If you're a side sleeper, sleeping on the left side is usually more comfortable for both aerophagia problems and acid reflux problems. Stomach sleeping can make both aerophagia and acid reflux worse, but back sleeping can help minimize them. Elevating the head of the bed might help or sleeping on a firm wedge. But just propping yourself up on a bunch of normal pillows might not do much to ease the problem. Some people will claim sleeping with your neck extended (as opposed to having your head curled toward your chest) will help, but that raises the question of whether sleeping in that position is so uncomfortable for you that you can't really sleep or not. I am someone who wants to sleep curled tightly into a little ball (i.e. fetal position), and so I never was willing to try using something like a soft cervical collar to force myself to keep my neck extended.
I'm already side sleeping on left side , Tried elevated bed or cushions and it wasnt for me, I do agree with you after testing soft cervical collar and mouth tape, it makes me really anxious before sleeping and I do feel really uncomfortable, I will try my best to first relax and have "pleasure" sleeping
robysue1 wrote:
Thu Nov 07, 2024 11:14 am

3) Aerophagia can be worse at higher pressures. Now the pressure you are using, 7cm, is not particularly high. But again, your mouth and stomach haven't read the textbook, and you are having problems with aerophagia at 7cm. You might want to try reducing the pressure just a bit, but that does risk increasing the AHI, potentially significantly. Or you might want to give dynamic mode another try. But if you try dynamic mode, I'd suggest a pressure range of 4-7cm rather than the 7-9cm that you tried before. (If breathing at 4cm makes you feel air starved, then bump that minimum pressure up to 5 or 6, but leave the max pressure at 7.)
Its very nice to hear, maybe I should try the nasal mask at first at 7cm pressure and if the mouth leak are massive, I will switch to 4-7 pressure
robysue1 wrote:
Thu Nov 07, 2024 11:14 am
4) When you wake up in the middle of the night wanting to take the mask off, ask yourself "What am I feeling? Why do I want to take the mask off?". Ozij has already given you some good advice on how to fight the tendency to just take the mask off and go back to sleep. I will add this, however: Sometimes that feeling of just wanting to take the mask off is triggered by the fear of aerophagia. Even now, I will sometimes wake up in the middle of the night with a stomach sending signals that it feels like it's on the verge of getting aerophagia. What I do when this happen is this: I turn the machine off, sit up in bed, and pull the mask away from my nose and simply relax sitting in bed for a few minutes while breathing through my nose. When I am ready to go back to sleep, it's easy to just let go of the mask and let it settle back on my nose and the turn the machine back on and lie back down to go to sleep. Note: I don't take the mask all the way off my head when I do this. Rather, I just gently pull the cushion far enough away from my face and nose that I can breathe "normally" for the few minutes that it takes my stomach and brain to settle down and decide they both want to go back to sleep.

If you wake up in the middle of the night with real aerophagia---as in your stomach is already feeling swollen and hurting, the best thing to do sometimes is to just get out of bed. Walk around for a few minutes and go to the bathroom. See if you can force yourself to get some of that excess air out through burping or farting. And go back to bed only after the stomach is feeling a bit better and you feel strong enough to face putting the mask on again. NOTE: This can be very difficult to do, but it's the only thing that I've found that works when I wake up with really bad aerophagia.
I do think you are right, and my body awake in fear of aerophagia, I will try to pay attention when I wake up to see if it either aerophagia or fear that awake me and do things accordingly
robysue1 wrote:
Thu Nov 07, 2024 11:14 am
6) You've asked whether turning your humidifier down might help the aerophagia. That's really a personal preference. My nose wants maximum humidification---if I turn my humidifier down, I'm more or less guaranteed to have a badly dried out nose in the morning. But other people find that their noses like a lot less humidification. Some people's noses don't want any additional humidity at all. In general when the humidity is too high, your nose will feel (or become) more congested using the CPAP than without it. And I suppose that if humidifier-induced congestion grows during the night, that might cause some mouth breathing, which requires the tongue to drop down off its proper location on the upper palate, which in turn could aggravate aerophagia. Turning down the humidifier is an easy experiment to try, and your nose will let you know (within a day or two) whether the new humidifier setting is too low for its comfort.
I will try to change a bit the humidification, what do you think a good procedure can be ?

Try first : Nasal mask
If not working : Pressure change
if not working : Humidifcation change

What do you think robysue1 ?


I would like to thank you very much for your very long post, it's very reassuring comparing to my sleep doctor (honestly it's not that much his fault, there's so few sleep doctors and a handfull of patients in France) or my others online experience,

So thank you from the bottom of my heart !

(Also props to you ozij for telling robysue !)

User avatar
robysue1
Posts: 1207
Joined: Sun Sep 18, 2022 3:39 pm
Location: Buffalo, NY

Re: Months on CPAP and still struggling

Post by robysue1 » Sat Nov 09, 2024 9:50 am

Spadin wrote:
Sat Nov 09, 2024 7:26 am
I will try to change a bit the humidification, what do you think a good procedure can be ?

Try first : Nasal mask
If not working : Pressure change
if not working : Humidifcation change

What do you think robysue1 ?
First, keep doing the tongue exercises every day. I do think in time they will help with both the leaks and the aerophagia.

As for the CPAP, I would recommend doing these three things immediately and at the same time:

1) Pick the mask that is most comfortable and easiest to get to sleep with and worry about leaks later. For most people with aerophagia problems, the aerophagia tends to be worse on nights where you spend a lot of time fighting to get to sleep and/or fighting to get back to sleep after numerous wakes. In other words, once your body learns to sleep more soundly with the machine, the nights where the aerophagia is bad enough to wake you up should start to decrease in number. And for now, don't worry about large leaks unless they're waking you or your partner up every night.

2) Change back to dynamic mode, but use a pressure range of 4-7cm for about a week and then reevaluate how things are going.. Your AHI may wind up substantially higher using 4-7cm instead of a fixed pressure of 7cm. But the idea is you're trying to find out whether lower pressures lead to less aerophagia. So unless the AHI skyrockets to something really horrible (as in close to your untreated AHI on your diagnostic sleep test), it's worth trading off a higher than desired AHI temporarily for less aerophagia right now. If you find yourself unable to breathe comfortably at 4cm when you first lay down, bump that minimum pressure up to 4.6 or 5.0.

3) Keep an "aerophagia" log. The idea is to keep this really really simple. Each morning when you wake up, write down your subjective estimate of how bad the aerophagia problem was during the night and make a note if you woke up in actual pain or if you woke up with some anxiety that the aerophagia might be getting started. You can use something really simple: Use a 0-5 scale to assess how bad the aerophagia was where 0 = no aerophagia during the night or when you woke up for the day and 5 = really, really bad aerophagia, as in enough to wake you up and leave you feeling bloated and in pain when you get up the next morning.

After using your most comfortable mask with dynamic mode set to 4-7cm for about a week, reevaluate the whole week's worth of data. That's when you can review the whole week's worth of data, including the subjective stuff in the aerophagia log. That will help you figure out whether massive leaks are correlated with the aerophagia and whether lower pressure seems to help with the aerophagia. In other words, "what to do next" comes out of analyzing the data once you have some data that you can analyze. If it's clear that you need more than 4-7cm of pressure to control the apnea, you can slowly start increasing the pressure range by 0.2 cm every few days while continuing to keep track of the aerophagia. Post your data here and I'll be happy to continue helping you.

As for the humidifier setting: I'd leave it alone for now unless you know that your nose doesn't like warm, steamy showers. If your nose gets clogged up when you take a warm steamy shower, then turn the humidifier down a notch at the same time that you start the experiment with the lower pressure range.

Keep me posted on what happens, particularly if you get discouraged during the week long experiment because you have a bad night or two.
Joined as robysue on 9/18/10. Forgot my password & the email I used was on a machine that has long since died & gone to computer heaven.

Correct number of posts is 7250 as robysue + what I have as robysue1

Profile pic: Frozen Niagara Falls

Spadin
Posts: 7
Joined: Sun Oct 27, 2024 4:21 pm

Re: Months on CPAP and still struggling

Post by Spadin » Mon Nov 25, 2024 1:03 pm

robysue1 wrote:
Sat Nov 09, 2024 9:50 am

Keep me posted on what happens, particularly if you get discouraged during the week long experiment because you have a bad night or two.
Hello robysue !

After two weeks I come back with new infos !

At first I tried Nasal mask with 4-7 range but the leaks (more like cheeks puffing) kept awakening me,

Then I switched to FFM 4-7 range, humidity 4-5, the aerophagia went down smoothly ! My nights are way longer (for exemple last week my average sleeping time was 7h02) but i'm a bit wore unstable than before, sometimes my day is smooth but sometimes i feel horrible, since friday I got an heated hose ! For helping with humidity condensation

Since the 4-7 range, it seems like the ESO (epoch severe obstruction) EMO (epoch mild obstruction) EFL (epoch flow limitation) went up, but AHI is still low, seems like the deep sleep is more "butchered" too with the famous leak spike

Few examples:
screenshot-20241123-130212.png
screenshot-20241123-130212.png (95.99 KiB) Viewed 3423 times
screenshot-20241125-195727.png
screenshot-20241125-195727.png (101.81 KiB) Viewed 3423 times

One thing to take in account, is that the longest night with Nasal mask showed good result and I felt good the next day (low RERA, low EFL/EMO/ESO, low aerophagia), it's just that leak and puff wake me up
screenshot-20241125-213902.png
screenshot-20241125-213902.png (96.19 KiB) Viewed 3400 times
Maybe we should go this direction ? And try more harder nasal mask ?

Or keep the FFM and up the pressure ?

I also remarked that with EPR, the EFL EMO ESO values were lower, maybe Give EPR another try ?

What do you think Robysue ?

OFC I can provide more screenshots (with notes of every nights about aerophagia/humidity and how I felt)

Thanks again for looking at my case, it means a lot for me

Kindly,
Killian

User avatar
robysue1
Posts: 1207
Joined: Sun Sep 18, 2022 3:39 pm
Location: Buffalo, NY

Re: Months on CPAP and still struggling with aerophagia issues

Post by robysue1 » Mon Nov 25, 2024 11:48 pm

Spadin wrote:
Mon Nov 25, 2024 1:03 pm
robysue1 wrote:
Sat Nov 09, 2024 9:50 am

Keep me posted on what happens, particularly if you get discouraged during the week long experiment because you have a bad night or two.
Hello robysue !

After two weeks I come back with new infos !
Thanks for posting the new info.

It's my bedtime, so I don't want to try to respond tonight, but I will write something tomorrow.
Joined as robysue on 9/18/10. Forgot my password & the email I used was on a machine that has long since died & gone to computer heaven.

Correct number of posts is 7250 as robysue + what I have as robysue1

Profile pic: Frozen Niagara Falls

Spadin
Posts: 7
Joined: Sun Oct 27, 2024 4:21 pm

Re: Months on CPAP and still struggling with aerophagia issues

Post by Spadin » Sat Nov 30, 2024 3:46 pm

robysue1 wrote:
Mon Nov 25, 2024 11:48 pm
Thanks for posting the new info.

It's my bedtime, so I don't want to try to respond tonight, but I will write something tomorrow.
Hello robysue ! I'm sorry if i'm bothering you, I was just checking if you forgot to reply

I'm sorry if my post comes off as rude, english is my second language and i'm not used to these kind of reply, so it's a direct french-> english translation :oops:

Thank you kindly

Killian