dsm wrote:My PB330 does not give resp rates anywhere near what I seem to be able to drum up from the Vpap III S & S/T ...
My regular machine is always the BP330 - as I often say, it is the best I have ever come across except it doesn't record nightly data -
Well, my first question would be, how do we really know what the PB330 is doing without at least some kind of objective data. But even with that, if the question is can one make definitive conclusions about SDB using a one-channel monitor (minute ventilation) like being able to differentiate normal, or controlled state
from "neat" CSDB
from "messy" CSDB
from CSR
the answer is you can't, because you can also generate at least a "messy" CSDB-looking Minute Ventilation waveform by Wake, by washing down an Effexor with a can of Mountain Dew at bedtime, and by a myriad of other things. However, if you can consistently generate stable waveforms on CPAP, and major disruption on aggressive BiPAP, then you gotta think that the latter is generating airway instability. Does this equate to CSDB? If everything's peachy on CPAP, then crazy on aggressive BiPAP, that's more of the "iatrogenic" SDB (you're
making it happen). Refer back to the "How To Mess Things Up With BiPAP" articles or the concept of jacking up the controller gain part of the "loop":
At a given chemical response (
PcrCO2), adding in pressure support (in this case Proportional Assist Ventilation) will increase the resultant minute ventilation (VE), and the wagon starts merrily careening down the hill (oh no, not THAT thing again!)
In striving for the definition of CompSAS (right, there isn't even any agreement on what to call CSDB) the Morgenthaler et al group at Mayo have a great concept where
Patients were considered to have the CompSAS if CPAP titration eliminated events defining OSAHS, but the residual central apnea index was 5 or more per hour or Cheyne-Stokes respiratory pattern became prominent and disruptive.
In other words, no central apnea, or more importantly, no residual central apnea after optimal therapy, then no CompSAS, CSDB or whatever you want to call it.
SAG