UPDATED: Really need recs for new mask

[Violet West]

Hi guys! Long time no see. I've been using my CPAP for several years now with minimal problems. My doc says my results are "perfect." Yes, it can be done! However, I've become frustrated with my Swift FX nano nasal pillow mask and am looking for recommendations. It's getting to be supremely annoying and I desperately need a new mask now.

I like the nasal pillows just fine -- it's the strap around the back that is giving me problems. I slip it under a ponytail, but even so, I'm forever yanking it down during the night in order to seat the pillows correctly.There seem to be a lot more options now; I wonder if you all have a recommendation.

It doesn't seem like we have a review section or anything, although I know there must be a lot of discussion. It's not like I can sample them and return, and they're not cheap. Further, I know there's no "perfect" mask. If I could just get the straps to stay put!

What do you think? I don't want a full face mask. What options do you like?

Thanks.

[Pugsy]

Have you ever bought from cpap.com? They now have free return insurance on all masks they sell. You can get your money back if you don't like it and you get it back to them within 30 days of when they ship it to you.

You might take a look at the mask in my profile.....no straps at all.

[Violet West]

I usually order from Amazon as it's much cheaper, but that's good to know. And wow, that's a cool one, although I'm very sensitive to adhesive, so probably not for me.

[Pugsy]

It's hypoallergenic adhesive....if you want to test it send me a PM with your name and address and I will send you a small sample to try and see if you have a problem with it or not.

[Violet West]

Thanks, Pugsy; I'll let you know.

[Violet West]

Decided to get a Fisker & Paykel Brevida mask. Will let you know how I like it.

[booksfan]

Hi guys! Long time no see. I've been using my CPAP for several years now with minimal problems. My doc says my results are "perfect." Yes, it can be done! However, I've become frustrated with my Swift FX nano nasal pillow mask and am looking for recommendations. It's getting to be supremely annoying and I desperately need a new mask now.

I like the nasal pillows just fine -- it's the strap around the back that is giving me problems. I slip it under a ponytail, but even so, I'm forever yanking it down during the night in order to seat the pillows correctly.There seem to be a lot more options now; I wonder if you all have a recommendation.

It doesn't seem like we have a review section or anything, although I know there must be a lot of discussion. It's not like I can sample them and return, and they're not cheap. Further, I know there's no "perfect" mask. If I could just get the straps to stay put!

What do you think? I don't want a full face mask. What options do you like?

Thanks.

If you decide the Brevida you ordered doesn't work for you, I'm with Pugsy in suggesting the Bleep. Like you, I had had a terrible time with the back strap riding up and causing the mask to shift throughout the night. Caused multiple wake ups due to the leaks from the the mask shifting out of position, leaking into my eyes, waking me and having to reposition. Also like you, I am sensitive to adhesive. The Bleep adhesive has caused me NO issues since March and the leak rate is incredibly low. No shifting out of place, even when I sleep on my side or stomach with my face in the pillow.

Good luck with the Brevida.

[Violet West]

Cool. Thanks, and I'll let you know.

[squid13]

If your mask is riding up put a piece of Velcro ( the piece that has all the prongs on it) on the inside of the mask strap in the back so it will catch to your hair and stay in place.

[Violet West]

ouch

[chunkyfrog]

Velcro only penetrates the top layer of hair; it never reaches my scalp.
Something softer, like puffy paint or silicone dots would be kinder to uncovered skin.

[squid13]

The Velcro is not intended to reach the scalp, it grabs the hair and I doubt it would really hurt.

[Becca8104]

I prefer the hose on my head, so the N30i & P30i are my favorite masks. I now have both and they are both comfortable for me. The P10 is a popular mask that most people like. Prior P10 lovers have switched to The Bleep mask, and if the straps are the issue for you, you should try the Bleep. I have not heard that people have issues with the tape.

[Dog Slobber]

I liked the ResMed P10, didn't like how it would stretch and become to loose to keep a good. Washing them shrunk them back down, I kept a few and then rotated them putting them in the wash.

Tried the ResMed N30i, didn't like the seal of the Nasal Cradle.

Tried the ResMed P30i, liked both the seal and the top mount.

I'm not sure the N30i or P30i would work for you. The placement of the straps looks similar to the Swift. The Swift straps are likely to as well.

I'd give the P10 a try, it's single / split strap never moved on me and allows a lot more flexibility I placement.

[Violet West]

Here's an update: I got the Brevida mask from F&P. It comes in two sizes: extra-small and small; and medium to large. I got the medium to large size, based on the fact that I use the medium nasal pillows with my Swift FX. NOPE! I had to go back and order the smaller size pillows, which did work.

The Brevida is . . okay. I kind of hate it, but I'm giving it a chance. The nasal pillow itself is much larger and covers more, creating (supposedly) a "seal" around your nose. If I need to scratch my nose or something, it breaks the seal and I have to re-seat the whole thing. In terms of positioning, it's harder to determine the right orientation by feel in the dark (something I thought the Swift FX did brilliantly).

I'm also getting a lot of dry mouth, which didn't seem to be a problem with me before. We'll see.